Best American Food in Buffalo

Farm~to~Table Eclectic Cuisine

Try our most popular items

Treat yourself to our must-try list that has everyone talking

View Full Menu

Halibut

Pan seared, tomato dill beurre blanc, lemon jasmine rice, grilled asparagus

Vegan Selection (with Tofu)

Zucchini and squash stuffed with sweet peas, quinoa, butter beans, red onion on a bed of jasmine rice with chimichurri sauce with tofu

Iron Tail Burger

Grilled 6 oz patty, topped with fontina cheese, pickled hot peppers, bacon onion jam, lemon aioli, and romaine, served with house cut fries

Pasta Bolognese

Beef & pork bolognese, basil, whipped ricotta, parmigiano-reggiano, bread crumbs, pappardelle

Vegan Selection

Zucchini and squash stuffed with sweet peas, quinoa, butter beans, red onion on a bed of jasmine rice with chimichurri sauce

Pasta Bolognese ◊◊◊

Beef & pork bolognese, basil, whipped ricotta, parmigiano-reggiano, bread crumbs, pappardelle

See our most popular items

Here’s a sneak peek of the items our customers can’t stop talking about

The Delaware

The Delaware
Visit our sister restaurant, The Delaware, in Kenmore, NY!
delawarepubandgrill.com

Freshly Made Ingredients

Freshly Made Ingredients
We offer exceptionally fresh ingredients that have been treated with utmost care. From our breakfast to dinner menus, we guarantee quality food that will satisfy any appetite. We hope to provide a space for our guests to enjoy special and unique dining experiences everyday – a haven from the hustle and bustle of life. And in addition to the exceptional flavor of every bite, you can look forward to indulging in delicious creations crafted with the freshest ingredients.

Wide Selection for American Cuisine

Wide Selection for American Cuisine
Iron Tail Tavern offers a wide selection of dishes inspired by the traditions of American cuisine. Our ingredients are always fresh and locally sourced, allowing us to craft the best flavor combinations and make sure that all our guests leave with a smile. For those looking for something to tantalize their taste buds, we’ve got it!

Beverages with Unique & Exquisite Flavor

Beverages with Unique & Exquisite Flavor
If you're looking for a unique and exquisite flavor that tantalizes your taste buds, delight in the pleasure of our liquors. From premium craft beers to bold and flavorful wines, these delightful beverages are sure to make any occasion a memorable one. With our convenient online ordering system and our unbeatable customer service team, you can be assured of an exceptional experience from start to finish. Whether you want to share a fun night in with friends or just add something unique and delicious to your next party, Iron Tail Tavern have something special for every occasion.
Order From Our Website

Order From Our Website

Order directly from our website to save money in fees, get faster service, earn free food via our rewards program, and support local business.
Order Now

The Best Memories are Made Around a Table.

The Best Memories are Made Around a Table.
Whether you enjoy our intimate dining room, bright and visible bar area, or our *NEW* dog-friendly, airy front patio - we’ve got the perfect table for you!

Iron Tail Tavern

Iron Tail Tavern
When you visit Iron Tail Tavern, you will understand why it is one the best locally-owned independent American restaurants in Buffalo. From our use of fresh ingredients to our unique approach in crafting each dish with love and care, let us show you the difference. This restaurant provides a classic American dining experience with all the modern comforts that make it special. So if you’re looking for an unforgettable meal and incredible service, visit us today! You won't want to miss out on the amazing food served up here every single day. We look forward to seeing you soon!

What our customers are saying

Check out our most recent reviews!

The food was so delicious! The hummus plate is a gigantic order that could definitely be split between four people. Their pricing was fairly decent and there were so many dishes that I wish I could have tried. Friendly service as well.

Shontay B.

Shontay B.

Great vibes and music. Clean and classy setting with a cute candle on every table. Very friendly and accommodating people. Will definitely be returning, absolutely loved my experience.

Marguerite S.

Marguerite S.

Tried brunch here on a Sunday and was not disappointed! We were the only table when we arrived and there were 8 of us. We started with mimosas, Irish coffees and two of the Shaksukas to share. The Shaksuka was so amazing and large enough to feed us all, so much flavor. For our meals we had Sausage Biscuits & Gravy, French Omelette, Iron Tail BUrger and Steak and Eggs which we all shared and loved everything. Our server was very attentive and the food was so delicious. We had a great time and would certainly be back!

Kelly H.

Kelly H.

Something for everyone even vegan and vegetarian, staff was friendly and the ambience was inviting, would definitely recommend, go check out this new place we are happy we did

Melissa B.

Melissa B.

Really great place! Love seeing a Rusty Nail on the cocktail menu. Friendly bartender, waiter, other customers and all around atmosphere. Delicious oysters and amazing butternut squash soup. One of the best burgers in Buffalo too. Also, the gnocchi was delicious.

Rob T.

Rob T.

Everything we got was amazing. Seafood was very fresh. Very nice ambiance and service was great as well. Would 100% return and recommend.

Diana E.

Diana E.

Iron Tail Tavern Rewards

Iron Tail Tavern Rewards

Join our rewards program to earn points, get free items, and stay up to date with us.

Frequently asked questions

We are known for the following: Chicken, Falafel, Calamari, Salads, Dinner, Lunch, American Food, Burgers, Pasta.

Our location